You have $100,000 to invest. Should you put it into the S&P 500 index fund or use it as a down payment on an investment property? This is one of the most important financial decisions you'll make, and the answer isn't the same for everyone. Let's compare these two paths with real numbers, considering returns, liquidity, taxes, effort, and risk.
2024-2025 Market Snapshot: What the Numbers Say
Before diving deep, here's what happened over the past decade (2015-2024):
- S&P 500 crushed it: Up 313.7% total (average 15.5% annually)
- Real Estate doubled: Case-Shiller Index up 96% (average 6.9% annually)
- But here's the twist: Leveraged real estate with rental income still competed
The stock market delivered exceptional returns during this bull run, but real estate investors using 25% down payment leverage and collecting rent told a different story. Let's break down both scenarios with hard data.
The Visual Comparison: 10, 20, and 30 Year Performance
$100K Investment Growth Over Time
Using historical averages: S&P 500 at 10% annually, Real Estate at 4% appreciation + 6% cash-on-cash return
Key Insights:
- Real estate dominates short-term due to 4:1 leverage amplifying returns (86% ahead at 10 years)
- The advantage shrinks dramatically: From +86% at 10yr → +42% at 20yr → S&P wins by 5% at 30yr
- Compounding wins eventually: S&P 500's exponential growth overtakes leveraged real estate after ~28 years
- Real estate assumes $100K down on $400K property; mortgage fully paid off by year 30
- These figures ignore 600-1,800 hours/decade of management time (valued at $30K-90K for professionals)
- S&P 500 requires zero time and offers instant liquidity; real estate takes 3-6 months to sell
Growth Trajectory: Watch Your Money Compound
Important Context: These projections use long-term historical averages (S&P 500 at 10%, real estate at 4% appreciation). The 2015-2024 period was exceptional with S&P 500 averaging 15.5% and real estate 6.9%, which would change these numbers significantly. Past performance doesn't guarantee future results.
The Central Question
You have $100,000 to invest. Should you put it into the S&P 500 index fund or use it as a down payment on an investment property?
This is one of the most important financial decisions you'll make, and the answer isn't the same for everyone. Let's compare these two paths with real numbers, considering returns, liquidity, taxes, effort, and risk.
Historical Returns: What the Data Shows
S&P 500 Performance
- Long-term average (1926-2024): ~10% annually (excluding dividends)
- Including dividends: ~11-12% total return historically
- Recent decade (2015-2024): 15.5% annually (313.7% total gain)
- 2023-2024 performance: 24% (2023) and 23% (2024) - exceptional years
- $100K invested (at 10% avg) grows to: $259K in 10 years
- Volatility: Can drop 30-50% during recessions (2008, 2020) but historically recovers within 3-5 years
Real Estate Investment Performance (2015-2024 Data)
Example: $100K down payment on $400K rental property
- Home price appreciation: Case-Shiller National Index rose 96% (2015-2024), averaging 6.9% annually
- 2024 rental yields: National average 6.51% gross yield (up from 6.10% in 2023)
- Typical rental income: $2,500/month ($30,000/year)
- Typical expenses: $1,500/month ($18,000/year including mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance)
- Net cash flow: $12,000/year (12% cash-on-cash return on $100K down)
- Mortgage pay-down: $6,000-8,000/year in equity buildup
- Total ROI: 8-12% average, with well-managed properties achieving 10-15%
10-year projection (using historical 4% appreciation average):
- Property value: $400K → $592K (+$192K appreciation at 4%)
- Mortgage balance: $300K → $220K (+$80K equity from pay-down)
- Total equity: $372K (from $100K down + appreciation + pay-down)
- Cash flow collected: $120K (10 years × $12K/year)
- Total: $372K equity + $120K cash = $492K
10-year projection (using 2015-2024 actual 6.9% appreciation):
- Property value: $400K → $784K (+$384K appreciation)
- Mortgage balance: $300K → $220K (+$80K equity from pay-down)
- Total equity: $564K (from $100K down + appreciation + pay-down)
- Cash flow collected: $108K (10 years × $10.8K/year, adjusted for expenses)
- Total: $564K equity + $108K cash = $672K
Winner on paper depends on the decade:
- Using historical averages: Real estate ($492K) beats S&P 500 ($259K at 10%)
- Using 2015-2024 actuals: Real estate ($672K) beats S&P 500 ($413K at 15.5%)
- But leverage explains the gap: 4:1 leverage amplifies 6.9% property gains to compete with 15.5% stock returns
But wait, this ignores several critical factors like time, liquidity, and risk...
Time and Effort: The Hidden Cost
S&P 500: Zero Ongoing Effort
- Set up automatic contributions: 30 minutes
- Annual rebalancing: 1 hour/year
- Tax filing: Simple 1099 form
- Total time commitment: ~2 hours per year
Rental Property: Active Management Required
- Tenant screening and showings: 10-20 hours per turnover
- Monthly rent collection and accounting: 2-3 hours/month
- Maintenance coordination: 3-5 hours/month
- Emergency repairs: Unpredictable (midnight calls)
- Tax filing: Schedule E, depreciation tracking, receipts
- Total time: 5-15 hours/month (60-180 hours/year)
Opportunity cost: If your time is worth $50/hour, property management costs you $3,000-9,000/year in lost income or leisure time.
Alternative: Hire property manager at 8-12% of rent ($2,400-3,600/year), reducing cash flow from $12K to $8,400-9,600.
Liquidity: When You Need Your Money
S&P 500: Perfect Liquidity
- Sell anytime during market hours (9:30am-4pm EST)
- Funds available in 2 business days (T+2 settlement)
- Sell partial amounts (no minimum)
- No transaction costs (most brokers)
- Market price guaranteed at execution
Real Estate: Poor Liquidity
- Selling timeline: 2-6 months (list, negotiate, close)
- Transaction costs: 6-10% (realtor fees, closing costs)
- Market dependent: May need to lower price in slow market
- Can't sell partial stake
- Forced hold during downturns
Example: Need $50K for emergency? From S&P 500, you have it in 2 days. From real estate, you might wait months or take a HELOC at 8-10% interest.
Tax Treatment: A Complex Comparison
S&P 500 Tax Benefits
- Long-term capital gains: 0%, 15%, or 20% (vs 22-37% ordinary income)
- Qualified dividends: Taxed at preferential rates
- Tax-deferred growth: No taxes until you sell
- Tax-loss harvesting: Offset gains with losses
- Simplicity: Single 1099 form, no complicated deductions
Real Estate Tax Advantages
- Depreciation: Deduct $7,000-14,000/year on $400K property (27.5-year schedule)
- Mortgage interest: Fully deductible on investment property
- Property tax: Fully deductible
- Operating expenses: Repairs, insurance, travel, home office
- 1031 exchange: Defer capital gains by rolling into new property
- Cash flow: Can be tax-free or low-tax after deductions
The catch: Depreciation recapture taxes you at 25% when you sell, potentially eliminating the benefit. 1031 exchanges work only if you buy another property (can't cash out).
Winner: Real estate has more tax advantages if you're in high tax brackets (32-37%) and plan to hold long-term. S&P 500 wins for simplicity and avoiding depreciation recapture.
Risk Analysis: What Can Go Wrong
S&P 500 Risks
- Market volatility: 30-50% drops during recessions (2000, 2008, 2020)
- Sequence risk: Bad timing (investing before crash) hurts returns
- No control: Can't influence company performance
- Inflation: Real returns vary with inflation
Mitigation: Time in market beats timing market. Hold 10+ years to ride out volatility. S&P 500 has never had negative returns over any 15-year period since 1926.
Real Estate Risks
- Bad tenants: Non-payment, damage, eviction costs ($5,000-15,000)
- Major repairs: Roof ($15K), HVAC ($8K), foundation ($20K+)
- Vacancy: 1-3 months between tenants = lost income
- Market downturns: 2008-2012 saw 20-50% price drops
- Concentration risk: All eggs in one property/location
- Regulation: Rent control, zoning changes, tenant protections
- Interest rate risk: ARMs can spike payments
Mitigation: Strong tenant screening, cash reserves (6-12 months expenses), fixed-rate mortgage, landlord insurance, diversify across multiple properties if possible.
Leverage: The Real Estate Advantage
Real estate's biggest advantage is leverage, where you control a $400K asset with only $100K down (25% down payment).
How Leverage Amplifies Returns
Example: Property appreciates 3% annually
- Property value: $400K → $412K (+$12K)
- Your equity: $100K → $112K (+$12K)
- Return on your money: 12% (from 3% property appreciation)
But leverage works both ways:
- If property drops 10%, you lose 40% of your down payment
- You still owe the full mortgage even if value drops
Can You Leverage S&P 500?
Yes, via margin trading (typically 2:1 leverage), but:
- Margin rates: 8-13% (vs 6-7% mortgage rates)
- Margin calls: Can be forced to sell during downturns
- Higher risk: Stock volatility + leverage = dangerous combination
Verdict: Real estate leverage is safer (fixed rate, no margin calls) and cheaper (6-7% mortgage) than stock margin (8-13%, forced liquidation risk).
2025 Market Outlook: What's Different Now?
Interest Rate Environment
The landscape has shifted dramatically from the 2015-2020 low-rate era:
- Mortgage rates in 2025: ~7% (vs 3-4% in 2020-2021)
- Impact on real estate: Monthly payments up 40-50% for same property value
- Impact on stocks: Higher rates make bonds competitive, potentially slowing stock gains
Real Estate Challenges in 2025
- Affordability crisis: Home prices up 96% since 2015, but wages haven't kept pace
- Rising operating costs: Property insurance up 20-50% in many markets, property taxes climbing
- Rent growth slowing: After pandemic boom, rents stabilizing or declining in many metros
- Investor competition: Institutional investors buying single-family rentals, driving up prices
Stock Market Positioning for 2025
- Valuation concerns: S&P 500 P/E ratios elevated after 2023-2024 surge
- Tech concentration: Top 7 stocks (Magnificent Seven) drive most returns - concentration risk
- Economic uncertainty: Recession fears, inflation concerns, geopolitical tensions
- Opportunity: Corrections create buying opportunities for patient investors
The Verdict for New Investors in 2025
Favor S&P 500 if:
- You're starting with less than $100K (real estate entry costs too high)
- Mortgage rates remain above 6% (reduces real estate cash flow significantly)
- You're in expensive coastal markets where rent-to-price ratios are poor (<0.5%)
- You want to avoid the complexity of landlording in an era of tenant-friendly regulations
Consider real estate if:
- You can find properties meeting the 1% rule (monthly rent ≥ 1% of purchase price)
- You're in markets with strong job growth and population inflows (Austin, Nashville, Phoenix, Tampa)
- You have skills/connections to reduce acquisition and maintenance costs
- You're willing to wait for rate cuts to refinance (potential opportunity in 2026-2027)
Best strategy for 2025: If rates drop to 5-6% in late 2025 or 2026, real estate becomes more attractive. Until then, building cash reserves via S&P 500 investments while waiting for better real estate entry points may be optimal.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose S&P 500 If You:
- Want 100% passive income (no management)
- Value liquidity (might need money in <5 years)
- Don't have time for property management
- Want to start small ($100/month contributions possible)
- Prefer diversification (500 companies vs 1 property)
- Live in expensive markets where rental yields are low
- Don't want to deal with tenants, repairs, regulations
- Already own your primary residence (diversification)
Choose Investment Property If You:
- Want tangible assets you can see and control
- Have time to manage (or can afford 8-12% for property manager)
- Can handle illiquidity (don't need money for 5-10+ years)
- Want to maximize tax benefits (depreciation, 1031 exchanges)
- Have handy skills to reduce maintenance costs
- Live in markets with strong rental yields (1% rule: rent ≥ 1% of purchase price)
- Want leverage to amplify returns
- Enjoy the landlord role and property management
Consider Both (Hybrid Approach)
Many successful investors do both:
- S&P 500 in retirement accounts: Max out 401k/IRA with index funds ($23,000-30,000/year)
- Real estate in taxable accounts: Use leverage, tax deductions, and cash flow
- Benefits: Diversification, passive + active income, different tax treatments
The Bottom Line
S&P 500: Better for passive investors, those needing liquidity, and people who value simplicity. Average ~10% annual returns with zero effort.
Real Estate: Better for active investors comfortable with management, those seeking tax benefits, and people who want leverage. Can return 12-15%+ but requires significant time and expertise.
Best answer: Most people should start with S&P 500 (max out retirement accounts), then add real estate once they have stable income, emergency fund, and time to manage properties.
Don't let real estate's higher returns on paper seduce you into ignoring the time, illiquidity, and concentration risks. And don't assume S&P 500 is "too boring", as boring often beats exciting in investing.
Use our calculators:
- Long Term Rental ROI Calculator - Model your rental property returns
- Rent vs Buy Calculator - Compare real estate to renting
Frequently Asked Questions
Is S&P 500 better than real estate investment?
S&P 500 historically returns ~10% annually with zero effort, perfect liquidity, and no management headaches. Real estate can return 8-12% including appreciation and cash flow, but requires active management, has poor liquidity, and needs significant capital. S&P 500 wins for passive investors and those needing liquidity. Real estate wins for those who want tangible assets, leverage benefits, and tax advantages like depreciation.
What returns more money: stocks or rental property?
$100K invested in S&P 500 at 10% annual return grows to $259K in 10 years (pure appreciation). $100K down payment on a $400K rental property with 3% appreciation + 6% cash-on-cash return grows to $538K equity + $100K cash flow = $638K total. Real estate appears to win, but this ignores time spent managing (5-10 hrs/month), vacancy, repairs, and the concentration risk of one property vs diversified index.
Can I lose money in S&P 500 or real estate?
Yes to both. S&P 500 can drop 30-50% during recessions (2008, 2020) but historically recovers within 3-5 years. Real estate can lose value during housing crashes (2008-2012), and you can lose money monthly if expenses exceed rent. S&P 500 risk is volatility you can't control. Real estate risk includes bad tenants, major repairs, market downturns, and inability to sell quickly. Diversification reduces risk in both.
What are the tax benefits of real estate vs S&P 500?
Real estate offers depreciation deductions (~$7,000-14,000/year on $400K property), mortgage interest deductions, and 1031 exchanges to defer capital gains. S&P 500 offers long-term capital gains rate (0-20% vs 22-37% ordinary income), qualified dividends taxed at lower rates, and no ongoing tax filing complexity. Real estate has superior tax benefits if you're in high tax brackets and actively manage properties. S&P 500 wins for simplicity and avoiding phantom income from depreciation recapture.
How much time does rental property management take?
Self-managing a rental property typically requires 5-15 hours per month including tenant communication, maintenance coordination, rent collection, accounting, and emergency calls. During tenant turnover, this spikes to 20-40 hours for marketing, showings, screening, and repairs. Property managers charge 8-12% of rent to handle this. S&P 500 requires zero ongoing time, just occasional rebalancing. Value your time: if you earn $50-100/hr professionally, property management costs you $3,000-18,000/year in opportunity cost.
Research Sources & Data
This analysis is based on comprehensive research from authoritative financial sources. All data cited represents the most current information available as of November 2025.
Stock Market Data Sources:
- S&P 500 Total Returns by Year Since 1926 - SlickCharts
- S&P 500 Historical Annual Returns (1927-2025) - Macrotrends
- REITs vs. Stocks: What Does the Data Say? - The Motley Fool
- Stocks vs. Real Estate Updated Chart - LongtermTrends
Real Estate Market Data Sources:
- S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index - Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED)
- Case Shiller National Home Price Index 2015-2024 - Statista
- Rental Yields in the United States in 2025 - Global Property Guide
- Average ROI of Real Estate: Historical Analysis & Statistics - iPropertyManagement
Comparative Analysis Sources:
- Real Estate vs. S&P 500 (2000–2025): 25-Year Inflation-Adjusted Return Analysis - The Penrose Team
- Real Estate Vs Stock Investing: Historical Performance - The Luxury Playbook
- Stocks vs Real Estate: Why 2025 Favors Stock Investments - HAR.com
- What is the Average Cash Flow on a Rental Property? - Steadily
All external links open in new tabs and are set to noopener for security. Data accuracy verified as of publication date.
Related Tools to Run Your Numbers
Use these calculators to analyze your investment options with real data: